If you’ve ever read a list of positive traits that a lot of people with autism possess, an inability to lie probably topped the list. It’s a common one, and just today, I read a post on Quora that would have been much more unbelievable if anyone but a child with autism had said it.
This child insisted that he had misbehaved in class, and had been punished by the principal by being forced to wear a placard that said “I am autistic and I have no friends.” Does this sound believable? No? Well, maybe it wasn’t true. But a child who has no reason to lie said it happened, and I’m inclined to believe it’s true, by experience. I advised the child’s parents to press charges on the school for attacking a child by making fun of their disability, violating several codes and human rights.
However, a lot of people with autism are accused of lying or exaggerating. I don’t think that’s fair. I’ve been accused of lying many times, and every time, I didn’t understand why I wasn’t believed.
So why are we not believed, when honesty is made such a big deal of on autism forums? Well, I have a theory. I have spoken on this blog about a seven-year-old I met with mild autism. He expressed a lot of irrational views, but I believed all of them. Why? Well, because I’d experienced a lot of them myself. We don’t like it when people push in front of us or run right on top of us, and we assume they did it on purpose (although running into and then over me and then continuing to run without looking back to see if I’d fallen over makes me think it WAS on purpose), even though a lot of those instances were probably just because the person didn’t notice they were doing it. We report those instances as we see them, not how it was.
We’re not lying. We are expressing what we see or understand. We might be reading the situation incorrectly, but that’s not a lie. It’s not a lie if a two-year-old thinks the number six comes before five. And it’s not a lie that someone pushed into you on purpose if you think it’s true, even if it isn’t. Both of those are mistakes. And we make mistakes to learn.
Let us have that luxury to learn. We don’t mean to lie. All we ask is that you listen, and not consider every mistake an intentional lie.